Italian Food Myths: Separating Fact From Fiction
America loves Italian food. And who can blame you? From cheesy, saucy pizzas to rich, hearty pasta dishes, there’s something about Italian cuisine that just feels like home. But over the years, a lot of what Americans consider “Italian food” has taken on a life of its own—sometimes staying true to tradition, other times becoming something entirely different.
As someone who grew up in Italy and brought my family’s recipes here to Spizzico, I’ve heard my fair share of food myths. So, let’s clear a few things up, shall we? Grab a slice of pizza (or a forkful of pasta), and let’s set the record straight.
Myth: Spaghetti and Meatballs is a Traditional Italian Dish
Ah, spaghetti and meatballs—perhaps the most “Italian” dish in America. Except, in Italy, you won’t find this dish the way you know it.
Fact: The Dish Comes from Italian-American Immigrants
In Italy, meatballs (polpette) are smaller, often made with leftover bread, and served on their own—not piled on top of a plate of spaghetti. Pasta, on the other hand, is usually paired with lighter sauces, and you won’t find massive meatballs drowning in tomato sauce.
So, where did spaghetti and meatballs come from? When Italians immigrated to America in the late 1800s and early 1900s, meat was more affordable here than it was back home. Naturally, they took the humble polpette, made them bigger, and added them to pasta; the rest is history. It may not be what Nonna served, but hey—it’s still delicious.
Myth: Pizza Was Invented in Italy
I get it. When you think of pizza, you think of Italy. But the truth is a little more complicated.
Fact: Several Countries Helped Shape Pizza as We Know It
Long before Naples became known for pizza, people across Greece and the Middle East were baking flatbreads with toppings. But it wasn’t until tomatoes arrived in Italy in the 16th century that the real magic happened. Naples took that flatbread idea, added sauce and cheese, and gave the world what we now call pizza.
So, while Italy didn’t exactly invent pizza, we definitely perfected it. And at Spizzico, we’re carrying on that tradition with family recipes that keep things as authentic as they should be (though we won’t judge if you fold your slice New York-style).
Myth: There’s Only One Right Way to Eat Pizza
Speaking of folding… some say you have to fold it. Others insist on a fork and knife. And Chicago? Well, that’s a whole different conversation.
Fact: Eat It However You Want—Just Enjoy It!
Whether you pick it up, fold it, or use a fork and knife, there’s no wrong way to enjoy pizza. Personally, I prefer to keep things simple—no need to overcomplicate a perfect slice. But at the end of the day, as long as you’re savoring every bite, you’re doing it right.
Myth: Authentic Italian Dishes Are Loaded with Cheese
If Hollywood and fast food chains have taught us anything, it’s that “real” Italian food comes with heaps of mozzarella, parmesan, and ricotta. But here’s the thing—
Fact: Italians Use Cheese Sparingly (But Purposefully)
In Italy, cheese isn’t about excess—it’s about balance. A sprinkle of Parmigiano-Reggiano here, a bit of fresh mozzarella there—it’s meant to enhance, not overpower. That doesn’t mean extra cheese is a bad thing (because, let’s be honest, melty mozzarella is hard to resist), but if you’re looking for the “real deal,” don’t expect cheese to steal the show.
Myth: American Italian Food Isn’t Authentic
This one gets me every time. Some folks will tell you that unless you’re eating in Italy, you’re not getting the real thing.
Fact: Italian Food in America Can Be Both Authentic and Unique
At Spizzico, we make our dishes the way my family made them back home—with real ingredients, time-honored techniques, and a whole lot of love. But Italian food isn’t just about following strict rules; it’s about bringing people together, sharing a meal, and making memories.
So, is every Italian dish in America 100% traditional? Maybe not. But that doesn’t mean it can’t be just as special.
Myth: All Italian Food is Unhealthy
Yes, Italian food includes cheese. And pasta. And yes, there’s plenty of bread. But that doesn’t mean it’s all heavy, unhealthy meals.
Fact: Italian Cuisine is Rooted in Fresh, Wholesome Ingredients
Real Italian cooking isn’t just about carbs and cheese—it’s about fresh vegetables, lean proteins, and high-quality olive oil. Many traditional dishes, like fresh seafood pastas, light tomato-based sauces, and hearty salads, are incredibly nutritious.
At Spizzico, we use fresh, simple ingredients to create dishes that are both satisfying and flavorful. Whether you want something rich and indulgent or light and refreshing, we’ve got something for everyone.
Come Taste Great Italian Food at Spizzico
At the end of the day, whether you love spaghetti and meatballs or a simple plate of cacio e pepe, Italian food is about joy, comfort, and tradition. At Spizzico, we’re proud to honor our roots while serving up dishes that bring people together.
So, come on in, grab a slice, twirl some pasta, and let’s keep the tradition alive—one delicious bite at a time.
Share