An Italian-American Thanksgiving: Why There’s Always Pasta Before the Turkey

Ask anyone who grew up in an Italian-American family about Thanksgiving, and you’ll probably hear the same story. The turkey was there, of course. So were the mashed potatoes, the stuffing, and the cranberry sauce. But before any of that hit the table, out came a steaming tray of lasagna or baked ziti. And everyone ate it, even knowing a full turkey dinner was still on the way.

At Spizzico Italian Kitchen in Arnold, this tradition is close to our hearts. Our owners are three friends from Monte di Procida, a small town outside Naples, and food has always been how we show love and bring people together. Thanksgiving may be an American holiday, but gathering around a big table with family and good food? That’s as Italian as it gets.

Where the Pasta Course Came From

When Italian immigrants arrived in the United States in the late 1800s and early 1900s, they embraced American holidays while holding on to the food traditions they brought with them. Thanksgiving was a natural fit. It was a day about family, abundance, and a long meal shared together.

In Italy, a proper holiday meal moves in courses. There’s antipasto to start, then a primo (usually pasta), followed by a secondo of meat or fish. So when Italian-American families sat down for Thanksgiving, it made perfect sense to serve the pasta first and the turkey second. The turkey simply became the secondo.

Generations later, many families still won’t consider it Thanksgiving without that tray of pasta. It’s a delicious reminder of where they came from.

Building Your Own Italian-American Thanksgiving

Want to bring a little of this tradition to your table this year? Here’s how to give your holiday an Italian touch, course by course.

Start with antipasto. Instead of chips and dip while the turkey rests, set out a platter of cured meats, cheeses, and grilled marinated vegetables. Our Antipasto Tradizionale tray serves 10 to 12 and keeps hungry guests happy without filling them up too much. Add a tray of Mozzarella Caprese for something fresh and bright.

Serve a pasta course. This is the heart of the tradition. Our Lasagna, layered with ricotta, meat sauce, parmigiano, and mozzarella, is a classic choice. Baked Ziti is another crowd-pleaser, and it holds up beautifully while the rest of the meal comes together. Feeding a vegetarian guest? Eggplant Parmigiana works as a hearty pasta-course alternative or a meatless main.

Keep the turkey, of course. Nobody’s saying you have to skip the bird. The pasta course is an addition, not a replacement. Just plan on smaller portions all around, or plan on plenty of leftovers.

Add a fresh salad. A crisp salad cuts through all that richness. Our Spinach Salad with apples, walnuts, and blue cheese crumbles, or the Nuts & Berries salad with dried cranberries and sliced almonds, both bring a festive fall feel to the table.

Let Us Handle Part of the Cooking

Thanksgiving is wonderful, but it’s also a lot of work. Between the turkey, the sides, the desserts, and cleaning the house before guests arrive, the person hosting rarely gets a minute to sit down.

That’s where our catering comes in. Our large pasta trays serve 12 to 15 people and our salad trays come in small (6 to 8) and large (12 to 15) sizes, so you can order exactly what you need. Let us take the pasta course and the antipasto off your plate, and you can focus on the turkey and the people you love.

Catering also makes Friendsgiving, office potlucks, and holiday get-togethers easier all season long. Hosting a group of coworkers or neighbors? A few pasta trays and a sub tray will feed everyone without anyone spending the day in the kitchen.

Don’t Forget the Night Before

The night before Thanksgiving is one of the busiest pizza nights of the year, and for good reason. Your kitchen is full of half-prepped dishes, family is arriving from out of town, and nobody wants to cook a second big meal. Pizza is the easy answer.

Make Wednesday night simple with a New York-style pie or one of our Detroit-style pizzas with crispy, caramelized cheese edges. Since Detroit-style is available in limited quantities, we recommend ordering ahead, especially on a busy holiday week.

Gather, Give Thanks, and Mangia

Whether you’re carrying on a family tradition or starting a new one, adding a pasta course to Thanksgiving is a delicious way to celebrate. It’s a reminder that the best holiday meals are about more than just the food. They’re about the people around the table and the stories that get passed down with every dish.

Ready to plan your holiday meal? Browse our catering menu and submit an inquiry, order online for pickup, or call us at 443-214-5121. You’ll find us at 1282 Bay Dale Drive in Arnold.

From our family to yours, Happy Thanksgiving. Buon appetito!

Share

Leave a Reply

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.